Kelleys Island Historical Association

About Kelleys Island Historical Association

The Kelleys Island Historical Association offers the historic Old Stone Church (built 1866) as a wedding and special event venue on Kelleys Island, Ohio. This intimate, non-denominational church is constructed of native limestone with arched windows, original wooden pews, and a restored pump organ. The interior seats approximately 75 guests with additional chairs available. The church is fully air-conditioned and heated, but has no running water or restrooms on site (nearby museum or public restrooms are available). The rental fee is $450 (with a $50 discount for KIHA members) plus a refundable $250 security deposit. No food or open flames are permitted inside; a tent may be set up in the front yard for casual gatherings. Parking is limited. The venue is not handicapped accessible.

The facts

Guests

75+ guests

Pricing note

Rental fee $450; $50 discount for KIHA members; refundable security deposit $250.

Last updated

October 2026

On the big wedding guides

• Not listed on WeddingWire (checked October 2026)
• Not listed on Zola (checked October 2026)

How to reach Kelleys Island Historical Association

• Website: kelleysislandhistorical.org
• Phone: (419) 746-2399
• Address: 224 Division St

Wedding venues near Kelleys Island Historical Association

• Wesley Lodge — Lakeside Marblehead, OH · up to 350 guests
• The Wave at Marblehead — Lakeside Marblehead, OH · up to 240 guests
• Twin Oast Brewing — Port Clinton, OH · up to 200 guests
• Put-in-Bay Resort Hotel & Conference Center — Put-in-Bay, OH · up to 500 guests
• Sunburst Harbor Marina — Marblehead, OH · up to 70 guests
• The Crew’s Nest — Put-in-Bay, OH · up to 400 guests
• Grand Islander Hotel — Put-in-Bay, OH
• Put-In-Bay Winery — Put-in-Bay, OH
• South Beach Resort Hotel — Marblehead, OH · up to 120 guests
• Catawba Island Club — Port Clinton, OH · up to 175 guests